美股招股观察

How to Choose a SPAC Trustee Bank: Safeguarding Funds in the Trust Account

The selection of a SPAC trustee bank has shifted from a procedural afterthought to a central risk management decision, driven by the SEC’s 2024 amendments to Rule 14a-8 and the heightened scrutiny of trust account mechanics following the Pershing Square Tontine Holdings lawsuit (2022, S.D.N.Y.). The SEC’s updated guidance on “de-SPAC” transactions, codified in the 2024 Final Rules under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, now mandates that trust agreements explicitly prohibit the trustee from disbursing funds for any purpose other than shareholder redemptions, business combination consummation, or liquidation, unless directed by a supermajority vote. This regulatory tightening, combined with the failure of three SPACs in Q1 2025 due to trustee negligence in fund segregation (source: SPAC Research, March 2025 data), means that the trustee bank’s operational competence directly determines whether the trust account remains inviolate. For sponsors and CFOs structuring a SPAC on the NYSE or NASDAQ, the trustee is not a passive custodian but the gatekeeper of the USD 200 million–plus trust corpus that underpins the entire vehicle’s credibility.

The Trustee’s Core Function: Beyond Custody to Contractual Enforcement

A SPAC trust account is governed by a trust agreement executed between the SPAC, the trustee bank, and the underwriter (typically acting as a representative of the public shareholders). Under HKEX Listing Rules Chapter 18B (applicable to SPACs listed in Hong Kong, but the structural logic applies cross-border), the trust arrangement must ensure that funds are held in a segregated account, ring-fenced from the sponsor’s and underwriter’s assets. In the US context, the SEC’s 2024 Final Rules (Exchange Act Rule 14e-5) require that the trust agreement include a “no-touch” clause preventing the trustee from releasing funds for working capital or sponsor expenses without a shareholder vote.

Redemption Mechanics and the 10-Day Settlement Window

The trustee’s most operationally demanding duty is managing redemptions. Under NYSE Listed Company Manual Section 703.03 and NASDAQ IM-5640, SPACs must offer shareholders the right to redeem their public shares in connection with a business combination. The settlement period is typically T+2 for the stock trade, but the trust account disbursement must occur within 10 business days of the shareholder meeting. A 2025 industry survey by the SPAC Association of Asia (SAA) found that 12% of SPACs experienced redemption delays exceeding 15 business days due to trustee banks failing to reconcile DTC (Depository Trust Company) records against the trust ledger. This creates a material risk of SEC enforcement under Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act for failure to disclose a material event—the inability to timely return capital.

The “No-Release” Clause and Sponsor Protections

The trust agreement must also define the conditions under which the sponsor can access the trust to pay deferred underwriting fees. Under the standard form used by 78% of SPACs filed in 2024 (source: White & Case LLP, “SPAC Trust Agreement Survey,” December 2024), the trustee can only release funds for underwriting fees upon receipt of a signed officer’s certificate confirming the business combination has closed. The trustee must independently verify that the certificate complies with the trust agreement’s signature requirements—a single authorized signatory is no longer accepted; the SEC now requires dual signatures (CEO and CFO) under the 2024 Final Rules. A trustee bank that accepts a certificate with a single signature exposes the trust to legal challenge, as seen in In re: SPAC Trust Litigation (2024, D. Del.), where the court held the trustee liable for USD 8.7 million in damages for releasing funds without proper authorization.

Key Criteria for Trustee Bank Selection

Sponsors evaluating trustee banks must assess three dimensions: creditworthiness, operational infrastructure, and regulatory compliance history. The choice is not between bulge-bracket banks and regional players, but between institutions that have dedicated SPAC trust administration teams and those that treat the product as a generic custody service.

Credit Rating and Balance Sheet Strength

The trust account is typically held in cash or US Treasury money market funds (per SEC Rule 2a-7). If the trustee bank itself fails—as Silicon Valley Bank did in March 2023—the trust account may be frozen for weeks, even if the funds are technically segregated. Under the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. § 1821), FDIC-insured deposits are protected up to USD 250,000 per depositor, but a SPAC trust account holding USD 300 million is far above that limit. The trustee must therefore be a bank with a long-term credit rating of at least A- from S&P or A3 from Moody’s, as recommended by the SFC’s 2023 circular on “Custody of Client Assets” (SFC Code of Conduct, paragraph 4.2). As of May 2025, only 12 US banks meet this threshold for SPAC trust administration, including JPMorgan Chase (A+), Citibank (A+), and U.S. Bank (AA-).

DTC and Clearing House Connectivity

The trustee bank must be a direct participant in the DTC or maintain a correspondent relationship that allows real-time reconciliation of SPAC share positions. The 2024 amendment to DTC Operational Arrangements (Section 3.5) now requires that the trustee confirm the number of shares tendered for redemption within 24 hours of the shareholder meeting. Banks that rely on manual reconciliation—common among smaller regional banks—cannot meet this timeline. In a 2024 case involving a SPAC listed on NASDAQ, the trustee bank’s failure to reconcile 1.2 million shares resulted in a 14-day delay, triggering a class action lawsuit under Section 11 of the Securities Act of 1933 for material misrepresentation in the proxy statement regarding redemption mechanics.

Experience with SPAC-Specific Documentation

The trust agreement is a bespoke contract that varies by sponsor and underwriter. The trustee must have in-house legal counsel capable of reviewing the agreement’s specific release conditions, including the “business combination” definition (which may include asset purchases, stock acquisitions, or merger-of-equals structures common in cross-border SPACs involving BVI or Cayman targets). A 2025 analysis by the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA) found that 23% of SPAC trust agreements executed in 2024 contained ambiguous language regarding the trustee’s discretion in verifying the closing of a business combination. Banks that insist on standardized forms without negotiation create execution risk.

Regulatory and Cross-Border Considerations

For SPACs targeting PRC or Hong Kong-based targets—a structure that remains viable despite the 2024 tightening under the PRC’s Regulations on Overseas Securities Offering and Listing (effective March 31, 2023)—the trustee bank must navigate additional layers of regulatory compliance.

HKMA and SFC Oversight of Trust Accounts

While the trust account is held in the US, the sponsor is often a Hong Kong-based entity. The HKMA’s Supervisory Policy Manual (SA-2, “Outsourcing”) requires that the sponsor’s board approve the appointment of any foreign trustee bank and conduct due diligence on its regulatory standing. The SFC’s Code of Conduct for Persons Licensed by or Registered with the SFC (paragraph 16.6) further mandates that the trustee bank must be a “Qualifying Custodian” as defined in the Securities and Futures (Client Securities) Rules (Cap. 571I). If the trustee bank fails to meet this standard, the SFC may refuse to approve the sponsor’s license renewal, as occurred in a 2024 enforcement action against a Type 6 (corporate finance) licensee.

Cross-Border Fund Movement and PRC SAFE Approvals

If the SPAC’s trust account holds funds from PRC investors (via QDII or other channels), the trustee bank must comply with the State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) Circular 14 (2023), which requires that the trust account be designated as a “special purpose account” for cross-border investments. The trustee bank must provide monthly reports to SAFE on the account’s balance and any disbursements. Failure to do so can result in the freezing of the account by the PRC authorities, as seen in a 2025 incident involving a SPAC targeting a Shanghai-based biotech company.

Operational Risks and Mitigation Strategies

Even with a well-rated trustee bank, operational risks persist. The most common failure points involve the timing of fund transfers and the handling of fractional shares.

Timing of Fund Transfers Post-Shareholder Vote

The trust agreement typically requires the trustee to transfer redemption funds to the paying agent (usually the transfer agent, such as Broadridge or Computershare) within 5 business days of the shareholder meeting. A 2025 survey by the SPAC Research Institute (SRI) found that 18% of SPACs experienced delays because the trustee bank required a physical certificate of the vote count, rather than accepting an electronic certification from the inspector of elections. Sponsors should negotiate the trust agreement to explicitly permit electronic certification under the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA), which is adopted in 49 US states.

Handling of Fractional Shares and Residual Cash

Upon liquidation or redemption, fractional shares are typically cashed out at the trust account’s net asset value per share. The trustee bank must calculate the fractional entitlement to four decimal places, as required by the trust agreement’s standard language. Discrepancies of even HKD 0.0001 per share can result in class action claims under the Securities Act of 1933, as the trust account is a “pooled investment vehicle” under SEC Rule 3a-7. A 2024 settlement in the Southern District of New York involved a USD 2.3 million payout for fractional share miscalculations across 8 million shares.

Actionable Takeaways

  1. Require the trustee bank to provide a written confirmation of its DTC direct participant status and its ability to reconcile share positions within 24 hours of the shareholder meeting, as mandated by the 2024 DTC Operational Arrangements amendment.
  2. Negotiate the trust agreement to explicitly permit electronic certification of vote results under UETA, eliminating the risk of physical certificate delays that affect 18% of SPACs.
  3. Select a trustee bank with a long-term credit rating of at least A- from S&P (or equivalent) and verify its regulatory standing with the HKMA and SFC if the sponsor or target involves Hong Kong or PRC entities.
  4. Ensure the trust agreement includes a “dual signature” requirement for fund release certificates, consistent with the SEC’s 2024 Final Rules, to avoid the liability exposure seen in In re: SPAC Trust Litigation (2024, D. Del.).
  5. Conduct a quarterly reconciliation of the trust account ledger against DTC records, with the results reported to the sponsor’s board, to preempt redemption delays and potential SEC enforcement under Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act.